ETW JOURNAL
FeaturesDemoPricingBlog Trading journal alternativesvs. Notionvs. Excel & Sheets Backtesting softwarevs. TradingViewvs. FX Replay
Comparison

ETW Journal vs FX Replay for Backtesting (2026)

We compare FX Replay, a dedicated browser-based backtesting platform, with ETW Journal — a trading journal that syncs MT5, MT4 and cTrader and includes backtesting, trade replay and prop firm tracking — to help you decide whether you need a specialist or an all-in-one.

Updated October 20262 platforms compared9 min read
Short on time? Here's the verdict.

FX Replay is a focused, capable backtester with a free tier and unlimited sessions on its Pro plan. ETW Journal comes at it from the other side: a live trading journal with backtesting, replay of your real trades, Prop Firm Sync and ETW AI built in, from $7 a month. If backtesting is all you do and you run many strategy tests at once, FX Replay Pro is hard to beat. If you want practice and live results reviewed in one place — for less than FX Replay's mid tier — ETW Journal is the better fit.

Choose ETW Journal if:

  • You want backtests, a live journal and prop firm tracking in one subscription
  • You want to replay your real executed trades from MT5 or cTrader, not just history
  • You want an AI that knows both your backtests and your live trading

FX Replay logoChoose FX Replay if:

  • You need unlimited backtesting sessions and trades (Pro)
  • You want a free plan to start backtesting today
  • You want seconds-level or futures data and tools like Monte Carlo simulation
Feature comparison

Side-by-Side Feature Comparison

Quick comparison — ETW Journal vs FX Replay

FeatureETW JournalFX Replay
Starting price
$7/mo Essential · $15/mo Pro
Free · Intermediate $17.99/mo · Pro $35/mo
Backtesting sessions
3 (Essential) · 10 (Pro)
2 (Free) · 10 (Intermediate) · Unlimited (Pro)
Timeframes
1m to 1D
Seconds-level data on Pro
Risk-based order sizing
By balance %, with stops & targets
Yes
Per-session analytics
Dashboard, day view, reports & notebook
Strategy analytics on paid plans
Live account journal
Auto-sync MT5, MT4, cTrader, TradeLocker, DXtrade
Journal focused on backtests; live sync on select platforms
Replay your real trades
Trade, day or what-if (Pro)
Built around historical sessions
Prop firm
Tracks real challenges, fees & payouts; rules checked on synced trades
Challenge-style simulations on historical data
AI
ETW AI reads your journal and the chart, can place backtest trades (Pro)
AI queries — limited on Intermediate, unlimited on Pro
Economic calendar
Built in, in your time zone
Built in; limited coverage on Intermediate
Mentors & community
ETW University, Mentor Mode, mentor playbooks
Community resources
Free plan
No — from $7/mo
Yes, with session and trade caps
Best for
Traders who want practice + live review in one tool
Heavy backtesters who test many strategies
IncludedPartial / with workaroundsNot available
All-in-one

One subscription, or two?

Backtesting is half of the loop. The other half is checking whether the model you practised holds up when real money is on the line — and that needs a journal of your live trades.

With FX Replay most traders still keep a separate journal for their live account. ETW Journal Pro bundles backtesting, a live journal synced from MT5, MT4, cTrader, TradeLocker or DXtrade, trade replay, Prop Firm Sync and ETW AI for $15 a month — less than FX Replay Intermediate on its own.

  • One login, one dataset, one set of reports
  • Compare a backtested model with the same model live
  • No exporting between tools

Two tools

FX Replay Intermediate$17.99
+ a separate live journal+ $$
Prop firm account tracking—
$17.99+ /mo, before your journal

ETW Journal Pro

10 backtesting sessions✓
Live journal: MT5 · MT4 · cTrader✓
Replay, ETW AI, Prop Firm Sync✓
$15 /mo, all in
ETW Journal · Dashboard
ETW Journal dashboard
Prop firms

Simulating a challenge vs. tracking your real one

FX Replay lets you rehearse challenge-style conditions — profit targets, drawdown and daily loss — on historical data. That's useful practice.

ETW's Prop Firm Sync works on the challenge you're actually sitting. Link a challenge or funded account to a synced journal account and every real trade is checked against your firm's profit target, max drawdown and daily-loss rules automatically. Fees, resets, payouts, passes and fails roll up into one net result across every firm.

ETW Journal · Prop Firm Sync
Prop Firm Sync dashboard with total spent, received, net result and pass rate
Challenge · FundedNext $5,000
A FundedNext challenge linked to a synced account with live rule checks
Replay

Replay history — or replay yourself

A historical replay shows you the market. Trade replay shows you you: ETW Journal puts your actual MT5 or cTrader entries, exits, stop and target back on the chart and lets you step through them, with your pre-trade checklist and notes alongside.

Replay one trade, a full day, or build a what-if scenario to see what would have happened if you'd held to target or skipped the revenge entry.

ETW Journal · Trade replay
ETW trade replay of a NAS100 short with pre-trade checklist and journal stats
ETW AI

AI that knows both sides of your trading

FX Replay's AI answers questions inside the platform, with a query allowance that depends on your plan. ETW AI works across everything ETW holds — backtests, live trades, notes, checklists and playbooks.

Ask what your biggest weakness is and it might point to missed session prep, skipped checklist items, or the fact that your backtested FVG model works in London but not New York. On a backtest chart you can ask it to read structure or place the trade for you.

ETW AI
ETW AI answering a question from the trader's own journal
ETW AI · at a glance
ETW AI charting a P&L heatmap by weekday and hour
Community

Learn from mentors who can see your real trades

ETW University lets you book sessions with verified ETW mentors and join live Spaces where mentors break down charts on screen. Mentor Mode goes further: your mentor sees your stats, trades, playbooks and journal read-only, and chats with you about them inside ETW Journal.

You can also open real playbooks from ETW mentors — rules, notes, charts and videos — and use them as templates for your own backtests.

ETW Journal · Mentor Mode
Mentor Mode: a mentor chatting with students inside ETW Journal
Pricing

How the pricing compares

FX Replay has a free tier and an unlimited Pro plan. ETW Journal is cheaper at every paid level and includes a live journal — but caps backtesting sessions at 3 or 10.

ETW Journal

Monthly billing · yearly saves 17%

Essential3 backtesting sessions, live journal, stats, reports
$7/mo
Pro10 sessions, ETW AI, trade replay, Mentor Mode, direct MT5/MT4 connect
$15/mo

Quarterly and yearly billing available. Cancel any time.

FX Replay logo

FX Replay

Monthly billing · yearly: $180 Intermediate, $350 Pro

Beginner2 sessions, 50 trades/session, 1 indicator
$0
Intermediate10 sessions, 200 trades/session, 3 indicators
$17.99/mo
ProUnlimited sessions, trades & indicators; seconds & futures data
$35/mo

FX Replay prices from fxreplay.com, checked October 2026.

Fair is fair

Where FX Replay genuinely wins

FX Replay is a strong specialist. If these points describe you, it may be the better tool.

A free plan

You can start backtesting on FX Replay without paying, with sessions and trades capped. ETW Journal has no free plan.

Unlimited sessions on Pro

If you run lots of strategy tests in parallel, FX Replay Pro's unlimited sessions and trades beat ETW Pro's 10 sessions.

Deeper data options

Seconds-level data, futures and expanded symbol coverage on Pro suit scalpers and futures traders.

Strategy analytics tools

Monte Carlo and risk-reward simulators on paid plans help stress-test a model's results.

Final verdict

ETW Journal vs FX Replay: which should you choose?

If backtesting is the main event — you test many models, need seconds or futures data, and want unlimited sessions — FX Replay Pro is purpose-built for you.

If you want your practice and your live trading in the same place, ETW Journal gives you backtesting sessions, a journal synced from MT5, MT4, cTrader, TradeLocker or DXtrade, replay of your real trades, Prop Firm Sync and ETW AI for $15 a month on Pro — or start with backtesting and the live journal on Essential for $7.

FAQ

ETW Journal vs FX Replay — Frequently Asked Questions

Does FX Replay have a free plan?

Yes. FX Replay's Beginner plan is free, with 2 backtesting sessions, 50 trades per session and 1 indicator. ETW Journal doesn't have a free plan; Essential starts at $7 a month.

How much does FX Replay cost?

FX Replay Intermediate is $17.99 a month ($180 a year) and Pro is $35 a month ($350 a year), based on its pricing page in October 2026.

Can ETW Journal replace FX Replay?

For many discretionary traders running a few strategy tests at a time, yes: ETW includes bar-by-bar backtesting from 1m to 1D with risk-based sizing, and adds a live journal, trade replay and prop tracking. If you need unlimited sessions or seconds-level data, FX Replay Pro is the better fit.

Can I journal my live trades in ETW Journal?

Yes — that's its core. ETW Journal syncs MT5, MT4, cTrader, TradeLocker and DXtrade accounts automatically and imports your full available history on first connect.

Which is cheaper, ETW Journal or FX Replay?

On paid plans, ETW Journal: Essential is $7 and Pro is $15 a month, versus $17.99 and $35 for FX Replay's paid tiers. FX Replay is cheaper only if its free plan covers what you need.

Does ETW Journal track prop firm challenges?

Yes. Prop Firm Sync tracks challenges and funded accounts — what you paid, the rules, payouts, passes and fails — and checks every synced trade against your firm's rules automatically.